Classes and Elites Research Seminar @ClassesElites
We host online seminars on social class and elites at the Department of sociology and human geography, University of Oslo. Tweets by @maren_toft @MagneFlemmen sv.uio.no/iss/forskning/… Joined December 2020-
Tweets71
-
Followers672
-
Following398
-
Likes50
Come join us next Friday for our first seminar of the semester. We are joined by no other than Michael Hartmann who will give a talk on business elites sv.uio.no/iss/forskning/…
PhD course: social class, power and inequality in Paris in late November. Covers theory of class, problems of intersectional analysis, class boundaries in Europe, class and child-rearing, education and class reproduction ++. Sign up and I’ll see you there! ntnu.edu/iss/sos8540
I've been looking forward to this seminar since last summer when first having the idea of bringing these brilliant minds together for one session. Hope many of you will join us for the discussion. @AnuKantola @BruCousin @JulesNaudet
I've been looking forward to this seminar since last summer when first having the idea of bringing these brilliant minds together for one session. Hope many of you will join us for the discussion. @AnuKantola @BruCousin @JulesNaudet
Really excited to be talking about #elites and #philanthropy at the @ClassesElites Seminar with @luna_inequality and @maren_toft today at 13:15! Join us :-) @IPSA_Elites @ObElitesSuisses @AfsElites
Really excited to be talking about #elites and #philanthropy at the @ClassesElites Seminar with @luna_inequality and @maren_toft today at 13:15! Join us :-) @IPSA_Elites @ObElitesSuisses @AfsElites
@AnneM_75 and @luna_inequality are visiting @ClassesElites today at 13.15! Join us ✨
@AnneM_75 and @luna_inequality are visiting @ClassesElites today at 13.15! Join us ✨
Today!! ✨
Another seminar coming up!! This time we bring together two of the brightest scholars on elite philanthropy today: @AnneM_75 and @luna_inequality ! Nov 4th and open to all- Save the date: sv.uio.no/iss/forskning/…
TODAY! Hope to see you there
TODAY! Hope to see you there
Very excited about our first session of the fall semester! Join us next week when Céline Bessière and Sibylle Gollac will discuss their new book "the gender of capital" @genre_du (zoom-link on our website) sv.uio.no/iss/forskning/…
Today! @WBottero and @ShamusKhan will join us at 14.15 CEST! See our website for more info and zoom-details ✨ sv.uio.no/iss/forskning/…
Today at 15.15 CEST! See our website for details and zoom-link sv.uio.no/iss/forskning/…
Looking forward to next week’s seminar series on the modern working class and inequality today!
This Thursday, we bring you cutting-edge research on symbolic boundaries. Patrick Sachweh of Uni Bremen did focus group interviews on boundary work and devised a survey based on it to see if it could be generalised. Free to all on Zoom! sv.uio.no/iss/forskning/…

Bourdieu, Work, and I... @BourdieuI
4K Followers 4K Following Official account of the #𝗕𝗪𝗜 Research Network — currently run by @SadiyaAkram and @[email protected] picture : Pierre Bourdieu & Annick Coupé (unionist)
☁️ Pierre Bataill... @pierre_bat
5K Followers 1K Following MCF @UGrenobleAlpes. Socio de l'éducation, des élites, du travail et de la culture. @afs_socio/#LaRAC team pp Morgane Fringand
Magnus Rasmussen @RasmussenMagnus
5K Followers 2K Following Associate professor (USN) studying historical development of welfare states, working time, unions, political parties and democracy.
ChristophEllersgaard @chellersgaard
5K Followers 595 Following Elite researcher (pun intended) Contact: +45 51789040
Claire Maxwell @maxwell_claire
814 Followers 601 Following Professor of Sociology, University of Copenhagen Elites, globally mobile professionals & their families, internationalisation of education
Daniel Laurison @Daniel_Laurison
12K Followers 5K Following Author of Producing Politics, Beacon Press also: https://t.co/4eJOeLhswO Sociologist. Carnegie Fellow. Trans, parent.
Dave O'Brien @DrDaveOBrien
9K Followers 5K Following Prof of Cultural & Creative Industries @UoMSALC & @NewBooksCritThe host. Culture is bad for you https://t.co/0SPJZ1QjG6 same at blu
Tore Wig @torewig
5K Followers 2K Following Professor of Political Science at University of Oslo. Research Professor at PRIO. Armed conflict, democracy and dictatorship, quantitative methods.
Kristoffer Kropp @KristofferKropp
618 Followers 781 Following Sociologist of sciences and knowledge, EU and social science, Associate Professor at @roskildeuni, member of @DetUngeAkademi
Thierry Rossier @ThierryRossier
997 Followers 1K Following Researcher at @DesSociales & @LSEsociology. Formerly at @ioa_cbs & @Unifr. Studying Elites, Inequality, Gender, Class, Power, Economics & Science
Sol Gamsu @SolGamsu
7K Followers 7K Following Higher education worker researching, teaching, tweeting education, power & inequality. Mostly own views. Past Pres DUCU, now branch treasurer. On bluesky etc
Benjamin Brundu-Gonza... @BenjaminBrunduG
938 Followers 2K Following PhD candidate @LSEsociology; looking into #class, #culture, #networks, #education, #inequality; award-winning sociology teacher; #FirstGen
Maren Toft @maren_toft
2K Followers 1K Following Professor of sociology, Uni Oslo | Member of @EuCulture | Co-organizer of @ClassesElites | Columnist @Morgenbladet | https://t.co/JNDKo5TToP 🍉
Anton Grau Larsen @antongrau
2K Followers 2K Following Sociologist working on elites, statistical programming and descriptive quantitative analysis. Roskilde University
Matt Reynolds @mrmfr
837 Followers 876 Following Domestic work, housing and misc rambles. Research @LSEsociology. https://t.co/6wVpqA4ACM All views 'my own' #habitus
OBELIS @ObElitesSuisses
1K Followers 1K Following Observatoire des Elites Suisses - Swiss Elite Observatory @unil @sspunil | Swiss Elite database | Summer school 2024 on "Elites, power and inequalities"
Mike Savage @MikeSav47032563
15K Followers 962 Following Prof @lsesociology & founding ex-Director of @LSEinequalities. I study culture, power & inequality. New book ‘The Return of Inequality’ out with @Harvard_Press
Carl Henrik Knutsen @carlhknutsen
5K Followers 2K Following Professor in Political Science, University of Oslo. Senior Researcher PRIO.
AfsElites @AfsElites
990 Followers 107 Following RT 42 : Sociologie des élites de l'Association Française de Sociologie | Aussi sur Bluesky : @rt42-afselites.bsky.social
An Pri @AnPri6
4 Followers 833 Following
Matt Bond @tugsandtost
3K Followers 4K Following Husband Dad of 2 Labour Socialist Son California Just Seen U Around 8 Dead Boys Hey Jude Brass Winter Loyalty Song Salome Seven Shades notoav 26march 25-13
Kinga Zawadzka @zawadzkakinga76
1 Followers 20 Following sociologist, assistant professor at IFiS PAN
Opsimath @ooopsimath
53 Followers 3K Following
🇵🇸🇱🇧🇮�... @_evergreenoak
206 Followers 1K Following Against the barbarians of the Zionist entity. «EU values» are a hoax.
daniel_s @daniel_sotoh
25 Followers 1K Following
nika corradi @nikacorradi
281 Followers 2K Following Sociologist I Data & Communication 👩🎓 @FF_CUNI🇨🇿 @DerbyUni🇬🇧 @EdinburghUni🏴 @UZH_ch🇨🇭
Giacomo Rella @giacomo_rella
1K Followers 5K Following Economist. Postdoc @UQAM. Macroeconomics, inequality.
Jonathan Buchmann @Jonathanvc_bu
42 Followers 325 Following sociology & polilitical science | @kieluni, @unijena |
Michael Vallely @VallMichael12
108 Followers 389 Following Postdoctoral Research Fellow at the Economic and Social Research Institute. Views my own. RTs not endorsements.
Shaun Cichon @ShaunCichon
43 Followers 5K Following
Hugo de Camps Mora @hcamps08
270 Followers 1K Following PhD student in Sociology @bbkpsychosocial. Previously at @lsesociology and upf. Llibertat: igualtat i fraternitat
INTERMAPS @IntermapsUpf
158 Followers 219 Following Intersectional inequalities from a spatial and emotional perspective | ERC Starting Grant 2021 | @PolitiquesUPF | Project led by Maria Rodó-Zárate @MariaRRZZ
Akshay Walia @WaliaAkshay
103 Followers 7K Following
S-Y Pan @S_Y_Pan
63 Followers 506 Following
Michele Debernardi @MicheDebernardi
145 Followers 1K Following Anthropology and Sociology PhD @GVAGrad
shannon kneis @shannonkneis
918 Followers 2K Following Only active on bluesky: @shannonkneis.bsky.social Commissioning social science books for @ManchesterUP @thebookseller and @printingcharity #RisingStar
Sarah Ganty @SarahGanty
983 Followers 674 Following JSD candidate @YaleLawSch |@frsFNRS Postdoc fellow @UClouvain_be | Immigration, human rights, poverty, (in)equality, merit & 🇪🇺 law
Mercy @StellaUs1727
1 Followers 128 Following
Paolo Chiocchetti @p_chiocchetti
2K Followers 4K Following Lecturer in British Politics at @GBZ_HUBerlin @HumboldtUni. British and European politics, European integration, radical left, public policy. Managing @PSA_IPSG
Mireia Almirall Llamb... @mirealmirall
289 Followers 744 Following Anar aprenent, també d'economia i d'història PhD student at @CEDemografia researching gender, division of labor, family dynamics, and social inequalities.
Jan Schulz-Gebhard @janschulz91
2K Followers 3K Following PostDoc @Econ_UniBA and @Plural_Bamberg. Interested in all things distribution & networks. Partner of @angebhard. Dad of two. He/him.
Rachel Théodore @rachel_theodore
8K Followers 910 Following Francesa-estadounidense adoptada por Chile. Doctora en Estudios Políticos. Profesora Asistente @CeasUmayor. Investigadora Adjunta @CentroCoes
Gijs Lambrechts @LambrechtsGijs
315 Followers 612 Following basketball, and working on a PhD about the far right and the environment @echo_vub - master in economic policy @ku_leuven and communication studies @vubrussel
meghna roy @meganthroy
1K Followers 1K Following (she/her) doctoral fellow in social anthropology @UniOslo researching psychotherapy in india • amateur painter
k @karolebek
8 Followers 420 Following
Phodde @Phodde12008
15 Followers 1K Following
matteolanoe.bsky.soci... @MatteoLanoe_
492 Followers 2K Following Sociology PhD candidate @ Sciences Po; Center for Research on Social inequalitieS
laland @laland463766
1 Followers 2K Following
Louise Ashley @drlouiseashley
1K Followers 2K Following Researching EDI, especially how social class influences access and career progression in 'elite' occupations (now including UK medicine).
Lívio Silva-Muller @lliviosilva
387 Followers 787 Following Sociologist at the Harvard Academy | Environment & Redistribution | Mixed-methods
Tomasz Drabowicz @tomdrabowicz
3K Followers 8K Following PhD @EUI_EU #QuantitativeMethods Le sociologue petit bourgeois de gauche « sans espoir mais non sans passion » RT/FAV/etc≠endorsement 🏳️🌈🇵🇱🇺🇦
benjamin @statsinthecity
8 Followers 93 Following
Carlos Ruiz LH @crls_ruiz
140 Followers 1K Following
Working_Class_Knowled... @wc_knowledge
39 Followers 50 Following
Pedro Araujo @Drope_Araujo
221 Followers 230 Following Sociologist @FORSresearch & @ObElitesSuisses | Power | Elites | Inequalities | Careers | Open Research Data | Now posting on Bluesky
Shane Jay Fabugais @shanegfabugais
19 Followers 267 Following Now, he is most ready to take the lead in bringing the existence of Siquijodnon literature to the consciousness of the people.
Josephine @josephinejbrtx
62 Followers 413 Following MRes Sociology @SciencesPo. Environmental emotions, green controversies, eco-habitus.
Adélaïde Martin | @... @adelaide_mrtn
95 Followers 389 Following ATER @UParisNanterre • PhD cand. @ISP_Cnrs w/ a focus on 🇰🇭៚ Member RT42 @AfsElites | Fellow @ICMigrations • Seminar @Migrapriv | Associate @irasecbangkok
Daniel Panduro @Danielpanduro
2K Followers 3K Following Far, Adjunkt og tillidsrepræsentant på @KBHprof. - Med en fortid som lærer og Kommunalbestyrelsesmedlem.
Charles Thibout @cthibout
3K Followers 2K Following MCF en science politique à Sciences Po Strasbourg, furetant à l'IRIS et chez Chronik #GAFAM #multinationales #champdupouvoir
Works of Bernard Lahi... @WorksofBLahire
366 Followers 419 Following References to the work of French sociologist B. L. in French, English, Spanish, Portuguese... Profil animé par un collectif d'étudiant.e.s du PT, ES & FR
Abubakar Muhammad Uma... @AbubakarMu14770
15 Followers 182 Following To strive to seek to find not yield!!
Michael Kajue @KajueMicha6827
4 Followers 29 Following
Simon Damn! @SimonDame4
186 Followers 1K Following Fan de comédies musicales, de métal et de Pierre Bourdieu | Travail sur la sexualité, le genre et la classe | (re)Tweet sur la politique et la sociologie Il/lui
SHEHANA SAJAD @ShehanaSajad
57 Followers 645 Following PhD student Sociology#class#religion#urban @JNU
☁️ Pierre Bataill... @pierre_bat
5K Followers 1K Following MCF @UGrenobleAlpes. Socio de l'éducation, des élites, du travail et de la culture. @afs_socio/#LaRAC team pp Morgane Fringand
Lars E.F. Johannessen @LarsJohannessen
1K Followers 734 Following Assoc Prof in Knowledge, Expertise & Professions @OsloMet; Tech, qual methods, theorizing; @[email protected] + @larsjohannessen.bsky.social
Lisa Mckenzie @redrumlisa
21K Followers 5K Following Working class academic. Anarchistic author. Think I look like Elsie Tanner but probably more Sue Pollard. [email protected]
Branko Milanovic @BrankoMilan
171K Followers 1K Following Income inequality, politics, history, soccer Research prof, Graduate Center CUNY; Visiting prof III, LSE Forthcoming "The Great Global Transformation" Nov 7
Magnus Rasmussen @RasmussenMagnus
5K Followers 2K Following Associate professor (USN) studying historical development of welfare states, working time, unions, political parties and democracy.
ChristophEllersgaard @chellersgaard
5K Followers 595 Following Elite researcher (pun intended) Contact: +45 51789040
Claire Maxwell @maxwell_claire
814 Followers 601 Following Professor of Sociology, University of Copenhagen Elites, globally mobile professionals & their families, internationalisation of education
Daniel Laurison @Daniel_Laurison
12K Followers 5K Following Author of Producing Politics, Beacon Press also: https://t.co/4eJOeLhswO Sociologist. Carnegie Fellow. Trans, parent.
Dave O'Brien @DrDaveOBrien
9K Followers 5K Following Prof of Cultural & Creative Industries @UoMSALC & @NewBooksCritThe host. Culture is bad for you https://t.co/0SPJZ1QjG6 same at blu
Tore Wig @torewig
5K Followers 2K Following Professor of Political Science at University of Oslo. Research Professor at PRIO. Armed conflict, democracy and dictatorship, quantitative methods.
BSA Bourdieu @BSABourdieuSG
6K Followers 826 Following Bringing together researchers with varying interests to advance scholarly thought and debate in issues pertaining to Bourdieu’s theoretical approach.
Kristoffer Kropp @KristofferKropp
618 Followers 781 Following Sociologist of sciences and knowledge, EU and social science, Associate Professor at @roskildeuni, member of @DetUngeAkademi
Thierry Rossier @ThierryRossier
997 Followers 1K Following Researcher at @DesSociales & @LSEsociology. Formerly at @ioa_cbs & @Unifr. Studying Elites, Inequality, Gender, Class, Power, Economics & Science
Sol Gamsu @SolGamsu
7K Followers 7K Following Higher education worker researching, teaching, tweeting education, power & inequality. Mostly own views. Past Pres DUCU, now branch treasurer. On bluesky etc
Maren Toft @maren_toft
2K Followers 1K Following Professor of sociology, Uni Oslo | Member of @EuCulture | Co-organizer of @ClassesElites | Columnist @Morgenbladet | https://t.co/JNDKo5TToP 🍉
Anton Grau Larsen @antongrau
2K Followers 2K Following Sociologist working on elites, statistical programming and descriptive quantitative analysis. Roskilde University
OBELIS @ObElitesSuisses
1K Followers 1K Following Observatoire des Elites Suisses - Swiss Elite Observatory @unil @sspunil | Swiss Elite database | Summer school 2024 on "Elites, power and inequalities"
Mads Meier Jæger @MadsJaeger
1K Followers 474 Following Professor of Sociology, University of Copenhagen. Inequality, mobility, taste, beauty, experiments. Member of Presidency for Rådet for Børns Læring 2021-2024.
Mike Savage @MikeSav47032563
15K Followers 962 Following Prof @lsesociology & founding ex-Director of @LSEinequalities. I study culture, power & inequality. New book ‘The Return of Inequality’ out with @Harvard_Press
Oscar Smallenbroek @OSmallenbroek
150 Followers 208 Following Sociologist - Stratification and Values Research
Leonora Dugonjic-Rodw... @dugonjic_rodwin
430 Followers 2K Following Sociologist-historian exploring privilege & exclusion in transnational settings | @Stockholm_Uni
Cyril Jayet @Cyril_Jayet
512 Followers 1K Following sociologist, political attitudes and social stratification, @LettresSorbonne https://t.co/1hpBLSEfGZ
Brooke Harrington @EBHarrington
16K Followers 467 Following Professor of Sociology, Dartmouth; views my own. Author, 'Offshore' https://t.co/iDVj8xvn9Q; words @washingtonpost @nytimes, @TheAtlantic & @Guardian
Bryan Boyle (@bryanbo... @bryanboyle121
549 Followers 815 Following Incoming Lecturer in Sociology at the Vrije Universiteit Brussel. Labour, culture & elites. Ethnographer of butlers. Member @BRISPO_VUB & @EuCulture.
The Gender of Capital @genre_du
3K Followers 713 Following Céline Bessière & Sibylle Gollac. In English @Harvard_Press 2023 / Bande dessinée avec Jeanne Puchol 2023 / Originally @Ed_LaDecouverte 2020
OOIR @ObserveIR
12K Followers 886 Following Trending papers from peer-reviewed journals. See also: https://t.co/cGm9IUEpxz (University Press Alert) And: https://t.co/0lO87mV1Lg (Think Tank Alert)
C-REX (@crexuio.bsky.... @CrexUiO
8K Followers 399 Following Center for Research on Extremism (C-REX): The Extreme Right, Hate Crime, and Political Violence, @UniOslo.
Jessica Benson-Egglen... @JBEgglenton
1K Followers 1K Following PhD @SHU_SIoE. Research into white, working-class girls, HE policy discourses & #WideningParticipation. Research Fellow @shucdare. @jessicab-e.bsky.social
Teddy @HolmesEJB
404 Followers 276 Following
Miles Corak @MilesCorak
7K Followers 304 Following Professor of economics @GC_CUNY Senior Scholar @stone_lis #socialmobility #childrights #inequality #cdnecon #EconTwitter
Saskia Sassen @SaskiaSassen
48K Followers 1K Following MyLatest book "CITIES AT WAR" (Columbia U Press 2020) MyLatest Award 2020: Geneva Picciotto Prize
marie_sneve @mariesneve
1K Followers 101 Following Nestleder i @raudt, samfunnsøkonom i Miljødirektoratet, bassist i @makingmarx og finnmarking 4 ever
Bruce Western @WesternBruce
7K Followers 719 Following Professor of sociology @Columbia and co-director of the Columbia University Justice Lab @CUJusticeLab
Sigrid Z. Heiberg @sigridzh
1K Followers 1K Following Grønn feminist. @Partiet. Leder i @Oslopartiet og bystyrerepresentant, 1. vara til Stortinget
Lluís Parcerisa @lluisparcerisa
1K Followers 5K Following PhD in Sociology. Assistant Professor at @UniBarcelona. Researching abt #platforms #datafication #teacherswork & #educationpolicy.
Thomas Tallaksen @ThomasTallaksen
1K Followers 1K Following Data Scientist at Norwegian Union of Municipal and General Employees (Fagforbundet)
LSE Cities @LSECities
47K Followers 1K Following An international centre carrying out research, education, advisory and engagement activities in the urban field @LSEnews. Follow us on LinkedIn for updates.
David Manley @david_j_manley
1K Followers 843 Following Dean of Science and Engineering | Professor of Human Geography | Urban Geographer | Visiting Fellow @tudelft
Ryan Davey @RyanDavey284
1K Followers 3K Following Anthropologist | The Personal Life of Debt: Coercion, Subjectivity & Inequality in Britain @BrisUniPress (2025)
Dr Carli Ria Rowell @CarliRiaRowell
2K Followers 3K Following Associate Prof @sussexsoccrim | SFAHA | @britsoci social class convenor | @genderanded exec | #globalinequality #class #workingclass #educationalinequalities
Dr Emmet Fox @EmGeFox
1K Followers 1K Following SETU Lecturer & researcher in sociology. Interested in sociology of #climatechange, Practice Theory and #Bourdieu. https://t.co/sx0OyGPC6E
Neil Lee @ndrlee
6K Followers 2K Following Professor of Economic Geography, LSE Buy my book: https://t.co/5EcFC0q9Qk
Ingvild Skogvold @ingvilfs
277 Followers 693 Following Daglig leder av Ranaregionen Næringsforening. Fra Vålerenga til Helgeland.
Tone Liodden @tonemaia
62 Followers 239 Following
Amsterdam Inequality @uva_amcis
601 Followers 17 Following Amsterdam Centre for Inequality Studies, University of Amsterdam http://t.co/3go7cuXsCV
Manifest Tidsskrift @manitidsskrift
4K Followers 1 Following Den breie venstresidas arena for intellektuell debatt på internett. Anbefaler også @manifesttanke og @forlagmanifest
Misbah Ul Islam @Misbahkhan3000
3 Followers 171 Following
Dr. Randall Collins @sociologicaleye
2K Followers 674 Following Professor of Sociology. Author of NAPOLEON NEVER SLEPT and CIVIL WAR TWO available @ https://t.co/ddqM4febCk. Credited for predicting fall of communism.
Airi-Alina Allaste @AiriAlina
585 Followers 487 Following professor of sociology @TallinnaYlikool, adjunct professor of sociology and youth research @aboakademi, VicePres @rc34youth
Michela Franceschelli @M_Franceschelli
472 Followers 984 Following Sociologist and researcher at @UCL interested in life transitions, inequalities and migration
Janna Bergsvik @jbrgsvk
58 Followers 47 Following
Jerome Roos @JeromeRoos
13K Followers 812 Following I've stopped using this platform. Now on Bluesky: https://t.co/qWhaPOVb15 And on Substack: https://t.co/8z2PBfF69w
Maarten van Ham @maarten_van_ham
2K Followers 787 Following Professor of Urban Geography Delft University of Technology & Head of Urbanism; Urban Studies; Neighborhood Effects; Segregation; Inequality; ERC laureate
Eirik Vold @e_vold
216 Followers 134 Following
Julius Elster @JuliusElster
544 Followers 420 Following Senior Lecturer in Sociology & Youth @londonmetuni Research: identity•youth•reflexivity•epistemology Ex-Project Manager @SpursOfficial @juliuselster.bsky.social
C.Wright Mills @CharlesWrightMi
13 Followers 12 Following Professor at Columbia University. Sociology. The Power Elite. 08/28/16-03/20/62
Sarah Steinitz @SarahSteinitz
1K Followers 2K Following Partner i Analyse og Tal, forfatter, sociolog og svært begejstret for de 🇩🇰 øer. [email protected] - Tlf. 28683460
Pere Ayling @AylingPere
207 Followers 109 Following Sociologist - Social theory, elite studies, Race & Ethnicity, Disability, Social class inequality, international education, Whiteness and research ethics
Thor Berger @bergerthor
786 Followers 657 Following Pro Futura Scientia Fellow XVI at Swedish Collegium (Uppsala University), Associate Professor at Lund University, and Research Affiliate at the CEPR and IFN.
Astra Taylor @astradisastra
38K Followers 2K Following director of documentaries, writer of books and essays, retired fuzz guitar Bluesky https://t.co/Fkp2IR2l70
Diliara Valeeva @diliara_valeeva
951 Followers 1K Following Assistant Professor in Computational Social Science at the University of Amsterdam | Posts on elites, finance, business, social networks.
Gunn Enli @gunnen
1K Followers 925 Following Vice Dean at the Faculty of Humanities, University of Oslo. Professor of Media Studies. Author of Mediated Authenticity.