If I got this paper as a referee, I would reject it for lack of proof. arxiv.org/abs/2201.03453 (For anyone who is interested, I can be more technical in DM or email, details are not twitter-friendly…) Here are a few general thoughts:
3
3
24
0
7
@spinespresso My postdoc advisor would quite often emphasize that science moves along not only with discoveries but also with criticisms. Thanks for your critical stance in this issue.
@davidUIB thanks. science can be ground to a halt by a flood of faux discoveries.
@spinespresso @davidUIB Unfortunately, a large enough stream of technically correct over-hyped ones is often enough.