Will Duffield @Will_Duffield
Internet Speech Governance. Policy Analyst @CatoInstitute. Unreasonable opinions are my own. Potomac Delta Joined October 2008-
Tweets5K
-
Followers2K
-
Following3K
-
Likes42K
"The past is a foreign country; they do things differently there." youtu.be/OHCRWfV1q5A?si…
The OSB doesn't release content examples, can certainly see why they didn't here, but it makes it impossible to make specific recommendations in these cases. The line between protected political expression and obscene defamation necessarily turns on realism/distinguishability .
The OSB doesn't release content examples, can certainly see why they didn't here, but it makes it impossible to make specific recommendations in these cases. The line between protected political expression and obscene defamation necessarily turns on realism/distinguishability .
“I have not been to a dinner with more than five AI people where there's a single agreement on how you would regulate AI.” Ditto. But if you are at a dinner table with five people who do agree, back away slowly since you are in a cult and the idea is bad. wired.com/story/tech-ai-…
TONIGHT! The premiere event of the season 🎬📽️ WHO WILL WIN in the battle between Miss Information + Free Speech? Don't miss @FedSoc's JAWBONED at @CatoInstitute #CatoEvents, featuring @nsaadbembridge @Will_Duffield @katieharbath & @adamkovac cato.org/events/jawbone…
TOMORROW: Don’t miss the premiere of @FedSoc’s “Jawboned: Free Speech vs. Miss Information” at @CatoInstitute! cato.org/events/jawbone… @nsaadbembridge @adamkovac @Will_Duffield @katieharbath #CatoEvents
Eric Dale : Do you know I built a bridge once? Will Emerson : Sorry? Eric Dale : A bridge. Will Emerson : No, I didn't know that. Eric Dale : I was an engineer by trade. Will Emerson : Hmmm... hmmm Eric Dale : It went from Dilles Bottom, Ohio to Moundsville, West Virginia.…
Eric Dale : Do you know I built a bridge once? Will Emerson : Sorry? Eric Dale : A bridge. Will Emerson : No, I didn't know that. Eric Dale : I was an engineer by trade. Will Emerson : Hmmm... hmmm Eric Dale : It went from Dilles Bottom, Ohio to Moundsville, West Virginia.…
The main real critique of getting smartphones out of classrooms seems to be a kind of generalized aversion to the idea of enforcing any rules. slowboring.com/p/smartphones-…
beyond excited to be part of this documentary! 🦸🏻♀️ in-person movie premiere event is next Thursday, April 11. Register below!
beyond excited to be part of this documentary! 🦸🏻♀️ in-person movie premiere event is next Thursday, April 11. Register below!
I know these AI folks are pretty new to policy, but this proposal is an outlandish, unprecedented, and abjectly unconstitutional system of prior restraint.
I know these AI folks are pretty new to policy, but this proposal is an outlandish, unprecedented, and abjectly unconstitutional system of prior restraint.
THURSDAY: Please join us for the premiere screening of “Jawboned: Miss Information vs. Free Speech” followed by a discussion and Q&A session with the director, @FedSoc’s Matt Wood, @Will_Duffield, @nsaadbembridge, and @dr_inserra. Register: cato.org/events/jawbone… #CatoEvents
Join us April 11 for the premiere screening of Jawboned: Miss Information vs. Free Speech, a new documentary by FedSoc Studios, investigating the distinctions between notification, persuasion, and unconstitutional government coercion, a key issue before the Supreme Court this…
do we care about tiktok or about this
Starship? I just want to use it to fly the SmartBird - festo.com/us/en/e/about-…
Starship? I just want to use it to fly the SmartBird - festo.com/us/en/e/about-… https://t.co/Oa0CjlFeW8
Scott Lincicome @scottlincicome
74K Followers 998 Following @CatoInstitute Vice President (Econ/Trade), @DukeLaw adjunct, @TheDispatch newsletter-er. CH❤️RTS. You didn't read the article, did you? Go @Rangers.Shoshana Weissmann, S.. @senatorshoshana
69K Followers 9K Following Digital Director & Fellow @RSI: Occupational licensing reform, social media regulation. @FedSocRTP. Fellow @SlothInstitute. Mountaineer. 12/58 CO 14er🏔📸 More⤵Patrick Hedger @pat_hedger
4K Followers 998 Following Executive Director of the Taxpayers Protection Alliance (@Protectaxpayers). Moderately-educated thoughts on policy. “Irrelevant.” - Sitting member of Congress.Sam Bowman @s8mb
49K Followers 2K Following Editor of https://t.co/YPQHCCb6Ke. Just here to have fun. COYS 🇺🇦Jennifer Huddleston @jrhuddles
4K Followers 2K Following Senior Fellow in Technology Policy at Cato. I tend to tweet about antitrust, data privacy, Section230, & running. All views are my own. RT/Like≠ endorsement.Jess Miers 🦝 @jess_miers
7K Followers 3K Following Senior Counsel @ProgressChamber | Adjunct Law Prof @santaclaralaw | Xoogler | Nerdy about 1A, #Section230, & Gen AI 🤖 | meme docent | tweets = mineNeil Chilson ⤴️�.. @neil_chilson
7K Followers 2K Following Lawyer, computer scientist & author of book 'Getting Out of Control.' Was chief technologist @FTC, now Head of AI Policy at Abundance Institute.Ari Cohn @AriCohn
32K Followers 4K Following First Amendment & defamation lawyer. Free Speech Counsel @techfreedom. Illini/music junkie/oofnik. Tweets my own. https://t.co/rn0IYL5Mr2 https://t.co/F6NjdYqLaQBen Sixsmith @BDSixsmith
45K Followers 2K Following Anglo writer in Poland. Online Editor and podcast critic for @TheCriticMag. Subscribe to THE ZONE on Substack.eigenrobot @eigenrobot
68K Followers 7K Following robot. friend. i am trying to achieve greatness longform at eigenrobot dot subst@ck dot comAdam Thierer @AdamThierer
10K Followers 2K Following innovation policy analyst at @RSI. Author of Permissionless Innovation (2016) & Evasive Entrepreneurs (2020). Harry Tuttle is my hero.The Alex Nowrasteh @AlexNowrasteh
25K Followers 1K Following @CatoInstitute VP Econ & Social Policy. Immigration. Globalist. Elitist. Cosmopolitan. “One-man factory” - @anncoulter. Dadx3. All tweets are peer reviewed.Rachel 🪻 @millionthrachel
4K Followers 2K Following amateur baker | external relations pro | well-behaved woman seldom making historyCato Institute @CatoInstitute
366K Followers 7K Following A public policy research organization dedicated to individual liberty, limited government, free markets, and peace.Andy Craig @AndrewRCraig
6K Followers 1K Following BlueSky:@ andycraig .bsky .social Threads: @ andy.craig Email: andy (at) andycraig .orgRobby Soave @robbysoave
112K Followers 2K Following @reason senior editor. @RisingTheHill host of Rising. "Sought-after player in Beltway's D&D circles" "noted scooter anthropologist" "baby Ryan Seacrest"New Liberals 🌐🇺.. @CNLiberalism
84K Followers 1K Following Liberal, Open, and Radically Pragmatic. The home for the center-left. Part of @NewDemocracyOliver Traldi @olivertraldi
27K Followers 5K Following Political Beliefs https://t.co/vHjAiR9xI1 @MadisonProgram @Princeton @Philosophy_NDWill Rinehart @WillRinehart
7K Followers 5K Following Senior Fellow @AEI. Author of the Techne newsletter @thedispatch. Economist focused on tech & innovation. Let's build something better.Jeffrey Westling @jeffreywestling
1K Followers 1K Following Director of Technology and Innovation Policy @AAF. formerly @RSI. #birdgang of the Arizona variety.JoyGosse @VRutV91ha21tS6
2 Followers 160 FollowingYa Jurez @JureJurez
47 Followers 5K FollowingVirginiaBray @r0fQhU1f3j1F9q
0 Followers 86 Followingsim1 @SimoneSyed
4K Followers 1K Following VC GP, industrialist, founder. Menace to the status quo. Techno optimist. Wholesome. 🇺🇲🏴☠️⏩ Investing in 🚀🤖🪙🧬🧠🏭👩💻💉📡💻☢️ American policy w/ @RSIBarbara @barbara_oldenbu
115 Followers 3K FollowingBailey Mehringer @BaileyMehr38969
75 Followers 5K FollowingAnnGeorge @9gCOuM9IM1kKV
1 Followers 149 FollowingSmoughez @smoughez42087
1 Followers 161 FollowingIndietarian @Indietarian
63 Followers 885 Following Playlist+community 4 DIY indie musical artists into freedom, peace, prosperity…dystopia, utopia, anarchy themes welcome;DM if this is U...others follow'n'like!Steven Godofsky @sgodofsk
5K Followers 584 Following Converting meat byproducts into bad tweets. @msbgu '20, @RITtigers '15, TJHSST '11.Publius @sci4punk
154 Followers 2K FollowingPia Pecorelli @PiaPecorel98833
32 Followers 5K FollowingJamir Sanford @JamirSanfo19629
13 Followers 719 Followingjeff12098357928 @jeff12098357928
0 Followers 2K FollowingLesha Ciccarone @CiccaroneL6894
79 Followers 5K Followingcrystal @crystalxduan
4K Followers 3K Following Tiger soccer mom | perfect anti-hero | communications consultations now avail 🚨 https://t.co/pOM20v3WaEKarl Meisenbach @RaisedReligious
246 Followers 742 Following Raised Religious? Most of us are. What could go wrong? Warning: Explicit Philosophy and Psychology.Vidushi Dyall @vidushi_law
320 Followers 329 Following @progresschamber Breaking down key developments in important tech cases you should be following. Tech policy, cybersecurity, competition. Fordham Law alum.Chelsey Sandovar @chels_sando
78 Followers 5K FollowingLawrence Spiwak @Lawrence_Spiwak
778 Followers 2K Following Professional Policy Wonk and Blues Musician (for official tweets see @lawandeconomics)eli אליהו🔯 @marketurbanists
370 Followers 1K Following rootless cosmopolitan shill // views expressed here are entirely my ownInnovators Network Fo.. @innov8rs
346 Followers 1K Following Advancing the public debate over law and policy important to global innovation. Home to the fellowships on privacy, antitrust, and intellectual property.Kaya Kaczmarski @Kaczmarski89219
38 Followers 5K FollowingKara Rollins @Kara_Mc_Rollins
374 Followers 1K Following Litigation Counsel @NCLALegal. Tweeting about administrative law, sports, motherhood, and DC living. Opinions are my own.Joe Schueller @schuellerj
400 Followers 734 FollowingMatthew Parkinson-Ben.. @L_I_Editor
1K Followers 2K Following Publisher @LittleIslandBks. The best new Irish writing for young readers, from toddlers to teens. Books create waves. He/himPromethea Bloodworth @P_Unbound
70 Followers 963 Following Science enthusiast, cosmic horror addict, Enlightenment romantic. To believe incorrectly is never a crime but simply to believe is never to have knowledge.Adham Bishr @abishr12
20 Followers 947 Followingmegabase @the_megabase
519 Followers 254 Following genomics/bioinformatics lackey, aDNA enthusiast. weakly penetrant. 3rd-generation denisovan-american. proud carrier of 16 hom LoFsElliotGaiser @ElliotGaiser
405 Followers 1K Following Law, culture, Ohio; personal account, posts do not necessarily reflect the views of my employer.Rita Cannistraro @r_cannistr
42 Followers 5K Followingnobody @netrunnernobody
997 Followers 163 Following nonsense in every direction. where do we go from here?Brianna Wachal @WachaBriann
80 Followers 5K FollowingGricelda Micallef @GriceldaMi41397
91 Followers 5K FollowingRetha Gravlin @RetGrav
54 Followers 5K FollowingEvalyn Moultrie @EvalynMoul85072
75 Followers 5K FollowingKatiya Palmisciano @katiy_k
58 Followers 5K FollowingTammie Savala @tamm_sav
34 Followers 5K FollowingScott Lincicome @scottlincicome
74K Followers 998 Following @CatoInstitute Vice President (Econ/Trade), @DukeLaw adjunct, @TheDispatch newsletter-er. CH❤️RTS. You didn't read the article, did you? Go @Rangers.Shoshana Weissmann, S.. @senatorshoshana
69K Followers 9K Following Digital Director & Fellow @RSI: Occupational licensing reform, social media regulation. @FedSocRTP. Fellow @SlothInstitute. Mountaineer. 12/58 CO 14er🏔📸 More⤵Patrick Hedger @pat_hedger
4K Followers 998 Following Executive Director of the Taxpayers Protection Alliance (@Protectaxpayers). Moderately-educated thoughts on policy. “Irrelevant.” - Sitting member of Congress.Sam Bowman @s8mb
49K Followers 2K Following Editor of https://t.co/YPQHCCb6Ke. Just here to have fun. COYS 🇺🇦Jennifer Huddleston @jrhuddles
4K Followers 2K Following Senior Fellow in Technology Policy at Cato. I tend to tweet about antitrust, data privacy, Section230, & running. All views are my own. RT/Like≠ endorsement.Jess Miers 🦝 @jess_miers
7K Followers 3K Following Senior Counsel @ProgressChamber | Adjunct Law Prof @santaclaralaw | Xoogler | Nerdy about 1A, #Section230, & Gen AI 🤖 | meme docent | tweets = mineNeil Chilson ⤴️�.. @neil_chilson
7K Followers 2K Following Lawyer, computer scientist & author of book 'Getting Out of Control.' Was chief technologist @FTC, now Head of AI Policy at Abundance Institute.Ari Cohn @AriCohn
32K Followers 4K Following First Amendment & defamation lawyer. Free Speech Counsel @techfreedom. Illini/music junkie/oofnik. Tweets my own. https://t.co/rn0IYL5Mr2 https://t.co/F6NjdYqLaQBen Sixsmith @BDSixsmith
45K Followers 2K Following Anglo writer in Poland. Online Editor and podcast critic for @TheCriticMag. Subscribe to THE ZONE on Substack.eigenrobot @eigenrobot
68K Followers 7K Following robot. friend. i am trying to achieve greatness longform at eigenrobot dot subst@ck dot comAdam Thierer @AdamThierer
10K Followers 2K Following innovation policy analyst at @RSI. Author of Permissionless Innovation (2016) & Evasive Entrepreneurs (2020). Harry Tuttle is my hero.The Alex Nowrasteh @AlexNowrasteh
25K Followers 1K Following @CatoInstitute VP Econ & Social Policy. Immigration. Globalist. Elitist. Cosmopolitan. “One-man factory” - @anncoulter. Dadx3. All tweets are peer reviewed.Clark Neily @ConLawWarrior
21K Followers 992 Following Senior VP @CatoInstitute / Constitutional & Legal Studies. Bane of bureaucrats & lover of liberty. https://t.co/w2vtdwOakUA lady @Anastasia_esq
6K Followers 2K Following Yeah, I’m a hammer. But every governmental abuse is a nail. I'm suing again. @PacificLegalRachel 🪻 @millionthrachel
4K Followers 2K Following amateur baker | external relations pro | well-behaved woman seldom making historyCato Institute @CatoInstitute
366K Followers 7K Following A public policy research organization dedicated to individual liberty, limited government, free markets, and peace.Andy Craig @AndrewRCraig
6K Followers 1K Following BlueSky:@ andycraig .bsky .social Threads: @ andy.craig Email: andy (at) andycraig .orgRobby Soave @robbysoave
112K Followers 2K Following @reason senior editor. @RisingTheHill host of Rising. "Sought-after player in Beltway's D&D circles" "noted scooter anthropologist" "baby Ryan Seacrest"New Liberals 🌐🇺.. @CNLiberalism
84K Followers 1K Following Liberal, Open, and Radically Pragmatic. The home for the center-left. Part of @NewDemocracyExTrac @Ex_Trac
6K Followers 0 Following AI-driven system tracking violence, forecasting risk, and mapping narrativesThe Rest Is History @TheRestHistory
127K Followers 151 Following History + bad accents, with @Holland_Tom & @DCSandbrook. From @GoalhangerPodsAbundance Institute @abundanceinst
2K Followers 11 Following Creating an environment for emerging technologies to grow, develop, and thriveCrémieux @cremieuxrecueil
88K Followers 907 Following I write about genetics, 'metrics, and demographics. Read my long-form writing at https://t.co/8hgA4nNS2A.Luna @Lunayian
4K Followers 1K Following Unhinged anime catgirl who rambles about AR/VR and gaming. [email protected]Replit ⠕ @Replit
122K Followers 1K Following Idea to software, fast. Build and deploy software collaboratively with the power of AI without spending a second on setup. Need help? @ReplitSupportMaximilien Robes @unclearirony
8K Followers 7K Following Artificial Intellectual • Diogenetics • https://t.co/REs3xiXH5AAriele 🌐🏗️ @weatherdai
3K Followers 521 Following Italian National Ponzi Scheme victim // monetarism strongest soldier (disputed) // Radicale 🌹// 🏳️⚧️🏳️🌈🇪🇺 alt: @weather_burnerSeaBD🍌🍌🍌 @deedreamerverse
2K Followers 1K Following Hello from the Far East🇵🇭 A woman in tech 🥳 Book nerd Pro-Democracy🇮🇱🇺🇸🇫🇷🇮🇳🇹🇼 Tweets about serious stuff + memes (Keeping it balanced 🤪)Scott Blackburn @ScottBlackburn2
83 Followers 205 Followingpositivity moon @arrtnem
23K Followers 5K Following Positivity is my state of mind. No, I'm not weird, you just didn't get my joke. See view more👇Ianclone2020 @Ianclone2020
13 Followers 50 Followingsercy🍀 @dogmadeath
903 Followers 498 Following 🤍 to mine own me be true ☀ to see everything at once 🌑 to face the fear 🌎 to build the futurePaul Schofield @pschofie79
14K Followers 7K Following Associate Professor of Philosophy, Bates College. Ethics, Politics, Film. Author of DUTY TO SELF (OUP, 2021). Researching housing justice and homelessness.Robert F. Kennedy🇺.. @sexyRFK
3K Followers 594 Following Call me Bobby. Look for me in the US Chamber of Commerce list of Ten Outstanding Young Men of 1954. Follow for ᶠᴬᶜᵀˢNeuralink @neuralink
1.4M Followers 1 Following Creating a general-purpose, high-bandwidth interface to the brainBrigid Delaney @BrigidWD
16K Followers 3K Following Labor speechwriter. Co- creator Netflix comedy Wellmania. Author Wellmania, Wild Things, This Restless Life, Reasons Not to Worry (Stoicism) .ex-guardian OzWifredo “Wifi” Fe.. @TheRealWifi
5K Followers 4K Following policy of the internets @GlobalAffairs @X | cofounder @thelabmiami | alum @Penn @AmericanU @MiamiLawSchool @TeachForAmericaSavvy | Artist @MadamSavvy
17K Followers 2K Following 31 | Creative Specialist | Commissions selectively open | Biology degree || actually allergic to the ☀️&🧄|| https://t.co/S2KQjGe4zEPuja Ohlhaver @pujaohlhaver
5K Followers 1K Following Pluralist, Technologist, Lawyer, Inventor, DeSochyperborean maude fla.. @txnftxnf
400 Followers 461 Following ml research, astrophysics, out of distribution living, differentiable rendering, autodiff of fixed points, optimal control, librarycore, pachinko engineerWhiskeypunk🧭 @Whiskeypunk1
827 Followers 920 Following The world offers you comfort. But you were not made for comfort. You were made for greatnessJustine Moore @venturetwins
56K Followers 894 Following Partner @a16z investing in all things AI 🤖 | Twin to @omooretweetsKrista Chavez @KristaAChavez
1K Followers 2K Following Senior Comms Manager @NetChoice. “The real danger to democracy is the administrative state's bottomless appetite for more power & control." Expecta Dominum.lina @linaeons
3K Followers 690 Following building. accelerate. agi cyborg augmented, molecular assembling, nanotech genetically engineered, nuclear powered, neural laced bci quantum supercomputer.Justin Hill @statelinx
452 Followers 796 Following State Gov Affairs Consultant, Tech Policy Strategist, Child Welfare Champion, Former MO State Lawmaker and Undercover Cop. @LibertyU grad & ⚽️ DadAda Palmer @Ada_Palmer
12K Followers 1K Following Historian (U Chicago), author SF/Fantasy, composer; @[email protected] Renaissance, censorship, manga, disability/chronic pain, gelato https://t.co/WmvGIcwgYhCasper Van Dien @caspervandien
6K Followers 214 Following Starship Troopers, Alita Battle Angel, Tarzan, Sleepy Hollow, All American, Mortal Kombat, Salvage MarinesAugustus Doricko @ADoricko
11K Followers 975 Following Making 💦 WATER ABUNDANT💦 @ RAINMAKER. DM to discuss deadlifts #beastmodetunient @tunient
1K Followers 372 Following having fun email: tun(at)airmail(dot)cc bsky: https://t.co/nRQx9nrzonDelphi @withdelphi
4K Followers 32 Following Scale 1-1 interactions, monetize your expertise, & deepen audience connections with your digital clone.Guardsman Miku @Guardsman_Miku
2K Followers 576 Following Bri*ish Drunk warwave posting since M31 Worlds #1 primaris hater alt: @guardsman_miku2 banner art: @Jun50450439074Garry Tan @garrytan
434K Followers 4K Following President & CEO @ycombinator —Founder @Initialized—PM/designer/engineer who helps founders—YouTuber—San Francisco Democrat accelerating the boom loop—e/acc, @Zvbear
162K Followers 5K FollowingNick Whitaker @ns_whit
3K Followers 1K Following founder, @worksinprogmag (@stripe), anti-cheems aktionTyler Austin Harper @Tyler_A_Harper
27K Followers 2K Following Contributing Writer @TheAtlantic. Teaching @BatesCollege. Professional Doom-Monger. Co-host of Time to Say Goodbye @ttsgpod. Red-Blooded Lacanian Male.realgoodkid @realgoodkid0
361 Followers 5K FollowingDimitri @TheDimitriT
767 Followers 427 Following equal parts apollonian (ml, probabilist, data scientist) and dionysian (bon vivant, reveler, shitposter). “Excellent!” - @nntalebkache (dingboard.com) @yacineMTB
53K Followers 3K Following i'm a swe. go to https://t.co/pWRBfY8kn2 - AI image editing IN YOUR BROWSER! follow to watch a self funded founder beat VC backed AI startups with @dingboard_Today at the local park with my 5 kids, I was told I needed a permit to be there with a group of more than 5 people. I said that they were my own kids and he said I still needed a permit!
Chaos in the background, and then there’s this guy sunbathing with a book
P.S. I use fourthwall.com to make them which is essentially a very good front end for Printful The founder is @dubbaumann and he's on here and very nice and responsive about bugs/feature reqs etc. Seems like a great company
.@UChicago really showing the benefits of having clear principals around speech
Blackthorne: To best position us for these opportunities a number of our teams made changes to become more efficient and work better, remove layers, and align their resources to their biggest product priorities. Mariko: The Anjin did layoffs to boost the stock price.
Should this become a listed structure?
NEWS // C20 Society has applied to list three site-specific dinosaur play sculptures at Teessaurus Park in Middlesbrough. Designed by Geneviève Glatt in 1977-79, they represent a rare major 20th century public-art commission for a female artist. ➡️ c20society.org.uk/news/listing-b…
thoughts from today: 1. if you often struggle to do things (take action, complete tasks etc) you may have a lot of unfelt anger in you. feel the anger. express the anger. you may find you have more energy to do things with 2. a great deal of your time can be spent avoiding
@FeralPHunter Hey im real sorry about your j6 conviction pawg hunter, this is good exp to share.
made a few updates to my running list of everything I've published on #ArtificialIntelligence policy, including analysis of latest federal bills. Next up is another piece on state #AI regulatory proposals & disastrous new Calif. bill in particular. medium.com/@AdamThierer/r…
@neontaster The number of people who just straight up never think about "politics" or "alliances" or whatever outside of a modern (or European) context is genuinely fascinating to me ... like, how do they think people lived?
The Carharttification of American fashion continues, just saw a woman leaving a workout class wearing a Makita sweater Bullish tbh
Learn more about this terrible bill. My friend @psychosort has a great thread
The California senate bill to crush OpenAI's competitors is fast tracked for a vote. This is the most brazen attempt to hurt startups and open source yet. 🧵
Today California State Senator Scott Weiner tried to defend his ill conceived proposal, SB 1047 which would undermine development of AI in California. He claims you can DM him to continue the dialogue, except his DMs are closed. Why lie about this?
This week's template: image2text with @Replit & @AnthropicAI I used the Anthropic SDK with Claude Sonnet to extract text from user uploaded images. The entire app took less than 30m to build and deploy.
Over the past few days there have been a number of attacks on non-custodial crypto services. - the Samourai Wallet indictment, which we believe includes some questionable charges - the government’s response in the case against Tornado Cash’s developers, which specifically…